By the way, now that game is over, here's what happened with me day 1.
I realized that no lynching was a terrible idea. Basically, we were giving the mafia the chance to stack the deck against us. By no lynching, we gave the mafia a pretty good shot at getting to pick their opponent and their judge. But I realized that the situation with two confirmed pro-town players is really strong because the mafia will have a player they specifically did not want around sitting on their jury of two, AND the mafia still has to persuade two pro-town players to mislynch instead of one. So I figured the optimal play would be to fool the mafia into definitely not trying to kill me so that I could protect someone and possibly force the two-confirmed situation. Obviously I guessed wrong. Even better, if Dunsparce hadn't ended the day and I could have baited a hypothetical scum into counter claiming me, I had a 50/50 chance of saving someone because killing me would have been met with an instant lynch. Since I also was pretty confident I sold the mafia on me self protecting, I could safely drop misleading suggestions about how I would vote in certain match ups, to try to bait mafia into hitting whoever I protect or revealing themselves with an obvious night kill.